Hermes Vector

PoliticsTrending

Google declines UK request to remove Russell Brand YouTube video

The UK government asked Google to remove a YouTube video in which Russell Brand's wife read his message claiming innocence. Google declined, saying its rules had not been broken.

By Hermes Vector

Also in: Español · Português · Français · 中文

Checked against 3 sourcesindependent.co.ukThe GuardianBBC
Illustration for: Google declines UK request to remove Russell Brand YouTube video

In brief

  • The UK government asked Google to remove a YouTube video featuring Russell Brand's wife reading his message claiming innocence.
  • Google declined the request, stating its rules had not been broken.
  • Housing minister Matthew Pennycook said the government has no power to mandate content removal.
  • Brand is serving a 10-and-a-half-year sentence for rape and three counts of sexual assault.

Google declines UK request to remove Russell Brand YouTube video

The UK government asked Google to remove a YouTube video in which Russell Brand's wife, Laura Gallacher, read a message from Brand in which he claimed: "I am not guilty of the offences I have been jailed for." Google declined the request, saying its rules had not been broken.

The request and the response

The Prison Service of England and Wales formally requested that the video be removed on the basis that it believed it was offensive to Brand's victims and had reached a substantial audience. A Ministry of Justice (MoJ) spokesperson said "it was only right" to ask for content that was "distressing for victims" to be removed, and added that while "removal ultimately depends on the platform's own terms", the department strongly believes "YouTube should remove this content."

Google told BBC News in a statement it was "aware of the new content and our teams are investigating." It added: "We suspended Russell Brand's channel from the YouTube Partner Program in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then."

Government position

Housing minister Matthew Pennycook said the government lacks the power to mandate a removal. Asked by the BBC's Breakfast programme if the government could force Google to remove the video, he said: "We don't have any power to mandate a removal of content. That is up to Google. It's based on their terms and conditions."

He added: "But as I've been very clear, we've made a request in this instance because we feel very strongly that victims shouldn't have to see this content." He also told Sky News the MoJ was in a "dialogue" with Google about the video.

The prime minister's spokesperson called the comments "clearly appalling." Downing Street added: "Prisoners are strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims, and speaking to the media is only permitted in exceptional circumstances."

Brand's situation and other reactions

Brand is serving a 10-and-a-half-year prison sentence after being convicted of rape and three counts of sexual assault. The Ministry of Justice launched an investigation into whether Brand broke prison rules by sharing the message. If he is found to have broken the rules, he could face sanctions including loss of privileges such as access to a phone for a limited period.

Education Secretary Lucy Powell criticised broadcasters for "amplifying" Brand's words by airing a clip of Laura Gallacher reading the message. She told LBC radio: "I was appalled at that, and actually I think mainstream media shouldn't have transmitted that either."

Jess Phillips, the former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, said the government "doesn't have the power to enforce that this video is taken down." She added: "It relies on YouTube, in this instance ... to do the right thing."

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said: "My personal opinion is that Russell Brand has been convicted. He is guilty under the law. The rule of law applies to everyone in this country." She also said: "But YouTube is a private platform. I think that immediately demanding the private platforms take things down without looking at exactly whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from."

Meta disabled Brand's Instagram and Facebook accounts after his conviction. The video and the Brands' YouTube account remain available on the site.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

Questions readers ask

Why did the UK government ask Google to remove the Russell Brand YouTube video?
The Prison Service of England and Wales requested removal because they believed the video was offensive to Brand's victims and had reached a substantial audience. A Ministry of Justice spokesperson stated it was right to ask for content that was distressing for victims to be removed.
What was Google's response to the UK government's request?
Google declined the request, stating that its rules had not been broken. The company confirmed it was aware of the content and investigating, noting that Brand's channel has not been able to monetize on YouTube since being suspended from the Partner Program in September 2023.
Does the UK government have the power to force Google to remove the video?
Housing minister Matthew Pennycook stated that the government lacks the power to mandate a removal, saying it is up to Google based on their terms and conditions. He added that the department is in dialogue with Google about the video.
What are the potential consequences for Russell Brand if he is found to have broken prison rules?
The Ministry of Justice launched an investigation into whether Brand broke prison rules by sharing the message. If found guilty of breaking the rules, he could face sanctions including loss of privileges such as access to a phone for a limited period.
How have other platforms and politicians reacted to the situation?
Meta disabled Brand's Instagram and Facebook accounts after his conviction, while the video remains available on YouTube. Education Secretary Lucy Powell criticized broadcasters for amplifying the words, and Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch argued that private platforms should not be demanded to take things down without looking at whether a law has been broken.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.