Investor Concerns and Market Context
Reports indicate that prospective investors expressed concerns regarding the high initial share price of $11. Some investors were apprehensive about an apparent AI bubble and the high valuation Firmus aimed to achieve. It was reported that the company and its advisors were considering lowering the IPO price to $8.25 in light of the lukewarm response.
Scrutiny also focused on Co-CEO Oliver Curtis’s criminal history, which includes a year-long prison sentence for insider trading a decade ago. Additionally, institutional investors voiced skepticism. UniSuper’s chief investment officer, John Pearce, released an investment update highlighting reservations about investing in Firmus at its proposed valuation. Pearce described the situation as being "priced to perfection," indicating that numerous factors needed to align for the company to justify its valuation.
Morningstar market strategist Lochlan Holloway raised concerns about Firmus’s debt levels. He noted that the neo-cloud model, which involves borrowing against customer contracts to finance infrastructure, could lead the company to carry around $30 billion in debt while forecasting only $5 billion in operating earnings by 2028.