Hermes Vector

PoliticsTrending

Colorado judge finds ICE officials in contempt over instant re-arrests

A Colorado federal judge held ICE officials and the government in contempt for re-arresting migrants immediately after court-ordered release, but declined further action after the practice stopped.

By Hermes Vector

Also in: Español · Português · Français · Deutsch · हिन्दी

Checked against 2 sourcesmprnews.orgnewsweek.com
Illustration for: Colorado judge finds ICE officials in contempt over instant re-arrests

In brief

  • A Colorado federal judge held ICE official Nichole Black and the government in contempt for instantly re-arresting a man after his court-ordered release.
  • Court records show ICE instantly re-arrested at least 18 people between Oct. 27 and Nov. 4, and those people have since been re-released.
  • The judge declined further action after an ICE official testified the agency had ceased the re-arrests following a Nov. 4 hearing.
  • Another Colorado judge, S. Kato Crews, called a similar instant re-arrest an ongoing due process violation and warned of contempt proceedings.

Colorado judge finds ICE officials in contempt over instant re-arrests

A Colorado federal judge held Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials and the government in contempt for instantly re-arresting migrants after judges had ordered their release, but declined to take further action because the practice has stopped.

The case

U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney ruled in Colorado that ICE officials violated her order to release Ramon Quintero Alvarez by October 28, unless the government showed cause to keep him detained. The Mexico-born father-of-two, who has lived in the U.S. since entering in the early 1990s, had been detained since February.

Sweeney said Black told the court Quintero Alvarez was released and "then 'walked out to the lobby,' exited the detention facility 'into a public area' where 'officers met him outside and rearrested him.'"

"Ms. Black said in her own words that she believed it was permissible to simply escort someone to a public area and immediately re-detain them despite a court order to the contrary," the Biden-appointed judge wrote in a 15-page order.

"This should—and, in the Court’s opinion, must—shock any reader."

Black said she knew of about 10 such cases, a figure the court said was later increased to 18.

The judge's order

Sweeney held Nichole Black, ICE’s assistant field office director in Denver, and the government in contempt for the re-arrest. She wrote that "the single thing" that saves Black and the government from further action by the court in this case is Rasper’s testimony that ICE had "ceased" these re-arrests as a result of the first evidentiary hearing Nov. 4. Sweeney wrote that "cured" the contempt, but reminded the government she considers Rasper’s pledge legally binding.

In a statement to MPR News last week, an unnamed ICE spokesperson wrote: "When appropriate, ICE will address the issues identified by the court and take further action consistent with applicable law and court orders, which can include rearresting an offender."

Background

Court records show ICE instantly re-arrested at least 18 people between Oct. 27 and Nov. 4, sometimes in batches. Those people have since been re-released.

In a separate case this month, U.S. District Judge S. Kato Crews ordered the administration to release Edgardo Garcia Vargas after ICE arrested him minutes after his court-ordered release. Crews called the re-arrest an "ongoing due process violation" and warned that another arrest without a hearing could lead to contempt proceedings.

In a Nov. 3 order, Crews said ICE never really released a man it instantly re-arrested and wrote: "Once again, the cruelty appears to be the point."

Crews cited decisions from two Minnesota judges who ruled similar re-arrests violated their release orders. Minnesota’s district court is split on the issue: while two judges have strongly condemned the re-arrests, two others have ruled the re-arrests did not violate their release orders.

MPR News has confirmed at least eight men have been instantly re-arrested at the Bishop Henry Whipple Federal Building after they were ordered released by a judge. One man was re-arrested twice.

Why it matters

The contempt finding shows a federal judge concluded ICE officials knowingly disobeyed a court order requiring a detainee’s release. The judge declined further penalties because the agency said it had stopped the practice, but she called the re-arrests a mockery of court orders and said the conduct should shock any reader.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

Questions readers ask

Who was held in contempt by a Colorado federal judge?
U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney held ICE official Nichole Black and the government in contempt for instantly re-arresting migrants after court-ordered releases.
What specific action by ICE officials violated the court order?
ICE officials escorted detainees to a public area and immediately rearrested them, such as Ramon Quintero Alvarez, despite a judge's order to release him by October 28.
Why did the judge decline to take further action against the officials?
Sweeney declined further action because ICE testified that it had ceased the re-arrest practice following an evidentiary hearing on Nov. 4.
How many people were instantly re-arrested between Oct. 27 and Nov. 4?
Court records show ICE instantly re-arrested at least 18 people during that period, a figure that increased from an initial count of about 10 cases known to Black.
What is the status of legal rulings on this issue in Minnesota?
Minnesota’s district court is split on the issue, with two judges condemning the re-arrests as violations and two others ruling they did not violate release orders.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.