Geopolitical dispute
Distillation is not illegal and is prevalent in other parts of the world. While the process cannot reproduce a leading model's full capabilities or eliminate the need for advanced computing power, it can help developers preserve selected skills in smaller systems that cost less to operate, potentially reducing their reliance on American technology.
Washington said on Monday it would further restrict China's access to such chips from companies like Nvidia. US authorities publicly accused Chinese companies in September of aggressive, targeted distillation of American AI models on an industrial scale.
At meetings in Chengdu in July, US Commerce Department officials raised concerns with Chinese regulators about developers collecting output from leading American AI models, warning that some activities could amount to intellectual-property theft, three people familiar with the discussions said. Chinese officials defended distillation as a standard AI-development technique and said they were open to acting where the conduct constituted IP theft, but made no concrete commitments, according to a US official familiar with the previously unreported exchange.
Among leading American AI companies, OpenAI's terms restrict using its output to develop competing models, subject to exceptions, while Anthropic similarly restricts training competing systems without permission.
A US official familiar with the July Chengdu regulatory discussions said Washington believes industrial-scale distillation is the main reason Chinese AI models have narrowed the gap with their American rivals. Two people familiar with Chinese developers' operations disputed that assessment, saying distillation was only one factor alongside advances in engineering, algorithms, data and model design.