Hermes Vector

Science

Two rival proofs of Riemann hypothesis emerge, one AI-assisted

Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge and Stanford researcher Alessandro Maria Masullo have each released claims of proving the Riemann hypothesis, which experts say require rigorous checking.

By Hermes Vector

Also in: Português · Français

Checked against 1 sourceNature
Illustration for: Two rival proofs of Riemann hypothesis emerge, one AI-assisted

In brief

  • Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge claims an AI-assisted proof of the Riemann hypothesis with Claude.
  • Stanford researcher Alessandro Maria Masullo released a separate, human-written proof preprint the same day.
  • Experts say both claims require rigorous checking before acceptance.
  • The Riemann hypothesis is a Millennium Prize Problem with a US$1 million prize.

Two rival proofs of Riemann hypothesis emerge, one AI-assisted

Two rival claims to have proven the Riemann hypothesis have emerged, one involving AI and one entirely human-written, and mathematicians say both need rigorous checking.

The claims

On 20 November, Levent Alpöge, a mathematician at Anthropic in San Francisco, California, announced that he had, working with Claude, Anthropic’s large language model, discovered a proof of the Riemann hypothesis. Hours later, Ravi Vakil, a mathematician at Stanford University in California, posted online a rival preprint written by Alessandro Maria Masullo, a mathematician who received his PhD at Stanford in 2020 under the supervision of number theorist Brian Conrad. Vakil described it as a “hurried announcement.”

Expert reactions

James Maynard, a Fields Medal winner and number theorist at the University of Oxford, said: “If this fully checks out, it is clearly a historic milestone in mathematics.” He also said he suspects the Alpöge proof will turn out to be correct, though it is in the form of incomprehensible code in the Lean programming language and will take a long time for mathematicians to digest.

Andrew Granville, a number theorist at the University of Montreal, said of Alpöge’s 4-page document: “What he released is garbled.” Granville cited the downturn in Anthropic’s stock value as the reason for the timing of the proof’s release, noting the company’s initial public offering initially valued it at US$1.5 trillion and its valuation dropped on 19 November. Alpöge wrote in the document: “There is an obvious cynical view, to do with the timing, but it is false.”

Tristan Buckmaster, a mathematician at New York University who collaborated with Alpöge on a separate project, said: “Levent himself built this amazing setup to do math.”

The problem

The Riemann hypothesis addresses the distribution of prime numbers and is one of the seven Millennium Prize Problems selected by the Clay Mathematics Institute, which offers a US$1 million prize for a solution. Bernhard Riemann, the German mathematician who formulated the problem in the mid-1800s, was born 200 years ago this September.

Why it matters

Confirmation of either or both solutions would be a landmark in mathematics. Maynard said that assuming mathematicians gain the corresponding understanding, the result would surely be viewed as one of the absolute pinnacles of mathematical results. Anthropic did not respond immediately to Nature’s request for comment.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

Questions readers ask

Who claimed to have proven the Riemann hypothesis and when?
Levent Alpöge announced a proof on 20 November, and Ravi Vakil posted a rival preprint by Alessandro Maria Masullo hours later.
What role did AI play in one of the proofs?
Levent Alpöge worked with Claude, Anthropic’s large language model, to discover his proof of the Riemann hypothesis.
Why is the Riemann hypothesis significant?
It addresses the distribution of prime numbers and is one of the seven Millennium Prize Problems selected by the Clay Mathematics Institute, which offers a US$1 million prize for a solution.
How did experts react to the claims?
James Maynard said it would be a historic milestone if it checks out, while Andrew Granville described Alpöge’s document as garbled.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.