Hermes Vector

Science

COP31 draft climate deal omits fossil fuels as talks stall in Turkey

The third draft of the COP31 climate deal in Antalya, Turkey, still does not mention fossil fuels, while activists and some countries criticize the text and warn the summit could end without an agreement.

By Hermes Vector

Checked against 2 sourcesdw.comBBC
Illustration for: COP31 draft climate deal omits fossil fuels as talks stall in Turkey

In brief

  • The third COP31 draft deal in Antalya, Turkey, does not mention fossil fuels, oil, coal, or phase out.
  • The draft retains a voluntary goal to raise electricity's share of global energy use to 35% by 2035.
  • Activists and several countries, including Panama and Tuvalu, say a fossil fuel mention is a red line for any agreement.
  • The draft acknowledges the world is on track to miss the goal of keeping temperatures below 1.5C of warming.

COP31 draft climate deal omits fossil fuels as talks stall in Turkey

Diplomats and delegates from nearly 200 countries are meeting in Antalya, Turkey, for the UN's COP31 climate summit. The talks have been extended past the original Friday deadline as countries remain divided over fossil fuels and climate financing.

The latest draft deal

The third draft makes no mention of the words "fossil," "oil," "coal," or "phase out." It retains a goal to boost electricity's share of global energy use to 35% by 2035, as well as efforts to expand the use of "clean energy." The draft text does not stipulate that the "35-by-35" electrification target should be met using renewable energy sources. It also urges countries to "accelerate" carbon capture and storage.

The draft refers to a 2023 agreement that committed the world to transitioning away from fossil fuels but stops short of naming them directly.

Reactions from countries and activists

Teresa Anderson, Climate Justice Lead at ActionAid International, said the people who will benefit most from the new "35-by-35" electrification targets and carbon capture "are the fossil fuel, nuclear, data and CCUS (carbon capture, use and storage) industries."

"This text will help elites to profit while leaving people in the dark," Anderson said.

Brandon Wu, AAUSA's Director of Policy and Campaigns, said: "Rich countries came to the COP31 talks with nothing to offer other than red lines."

"This is the behaviour of an arrogant bully who cares about nothing but himself and it is no way to have a proper negotiation. COP31 was one of the worst COPs ever, and it's because the EU and other developed countries came with zero spirit of solidarity, cooperation or compromise."

Harjeet Singh, the global convener of the Fill the Fund campaign and strategic advisor to the Fossil Fuel Treaty Initiative, said: "COP31 is stuck for one simple reason: money. Europe and other rich countries came to Antalya with empty pockets."

"They've spent two weeks pushing electrification targets and demanding more ambition from developing countries, while refusing to pay for any of it," he added.

The head of Peru's delegation, Andres Martin Garrido Sanchez, warned that the summit was unlikely to end with a concrete deal on climate financing or cutting fossil fuel use. He said geopolitical divisions were stopping any final deal from mentioning reducing reliance on oil, gas and coal.

Key disputes

Ministers from Panama, Solomon Islands, Cote d'Ivoire and the EU were fighting to have a commitment to move away from fossil fuels put back into the final agreement, after fossil fuel producers led by Saudi Arabia pushed for its removal.

"It is not acceptable to have a COP or a cover decision that does not even mention fossil fuels and we simply will not put up with it," said Juan Carlos Navarro, Panama's minister for the environment.

Tuvalu's Climate Minister Maina Talia told reporters it was a "red line" for the low-lying Pacific nation: "We're talking about the root cause of all of this."

France's Minister of Ecological Transition, Monique Barbut, took aim at several references in the text to carbon capture, use and storage (CCUS) as a licence for other countries to keep burning oil and gas.

Australia's Climate Change and Energy Minister, Chris Bowen, who is leading negotiations, pushed back on the need to include language on fossil fuels. He argued the summit was about implementation, and should focus on the move towards clean energy sources.

Zanetor Agyeman Rawlings, Ghana's Environment Minister and chair of the African Group of negotiators, said: "We did not come here to beg, we came here to claim what is rightfully ours for our people who are suffering the brunt of anthropogenic activities of developed countries."

Why it matters

The summit could end with no deal if countries cannot reach consensus, as required by the UN's climate talks process. This has only happened once before since countries started holding COP climate meetings in 1995. The latest draft also includes for the first time a recognition that the world is on track to miss the crucial goal of keeping temperatures below 1.5C of warming.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.

Science

Curiosity rover finds pure sulfur rocks on Mars

NASA's Curiosity rover cracked open a rock in Mars' Gediz Vallis channel and exposed yellow crystals of pure elemental sulfur, the first such detection on the planet.

Checked against 5 sourcesdw.comforo3d.comlatimes.com+2 more