Hermes Vector

Politics

Second Federal Judge Blocks Trump's Proposed Triumphal Arch

A Virginia judge has said she would issue a preliminary injunction to block construction of President Donald Trump's proposed 250-foot arch near the Lincoln Memorial, citing legal defects and lack of congressional approval.

By Hermes Vector

Also in: Español · Português · Français · Deutsch

Checked against 2 sourcespolitico.comThe Guardian
Illustration for: Second Federal Judge Blocks Trump's Proposed Triumphal Arch

In brief

  • Judge Leonie Brinkema said she would issue a preliminary injunction to block construction of the proposed 250-foot arch.
  • Brinkema cited multiple legal defects and a lack of adequate analysis of traffic and airport impacts.
  • Judge Tanya Chutkan previously temporarily blocked construction and extended her order until the beginning of December.
  • The administration argues 1925 congressional authorization of columns permits the project, which judges have rejected.

Second Federal Judge Blocks Trump's Proposed Triumphal Arch

A second federal judge has moved to block President Donald Trump's bid to construct a massive, 250-foot arch alongside the Potomac River across from the Lincoln Memorial.

Court Ruling

U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema said Friday that the plan suffers from multiple legal defects and that there was no evidence federal officials had adequately considered potentially serious impacts on road traffic and on Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport, which sits about three miles south of the proposed site.

"It seems like a rush job," Brinkema said during a hearing on a lawsuit brought last month by Arlington County, Virginia. "I don't see any way where the defense could be successful on the merits in this case.....You don't have Congressional approval for this project."

Brinkema, a Clinton appointee, also flatly rejected the Justice Department's argument that a 1925 law authorizing the construction of the nearby Memorial Bridge also gave federal agencies the authority to begin construction of Trump's proposed Triumphal Arch over a century later.

Previous Ruling

Earlier this month, Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington temporarily blocked construction of the triumphal arch. Chutkan extended her order this week, barring the administration from initiating any construction or demolition until the beginning of December.

Background

Over the last year, Trump has boasted about building an arch in the middle of the nation's capital to mark the US's 250th anniversary. He has sought to hurriedly build the arch, arguing it is for national security purposes because it will include a military complex.

Trump's arch has been met with legal challenges from veterans groups, local governments and individuals such as members of the Kennedy family. Critics have taken issue with the arch's enormous size and location, believing it would hurt the symbolic relationship between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington national cemetery.

Challengers have argued the US president needed authorization from Congress before constructing the arch. But lawyers for the administration claim they do not because Congress approved the construction of a pair of columns at the location in 1925, though the columns were never built.

On Friday, Brinkema said the administration's argument about the 1925 congressional authorization of columns was weak.

"It hurts your credibility with the court by focusing on that," the judge told government lawyers. "This is a project that lacks congressional approval."

Why it matters

The rulings by two federal judges prevent the administration from moving forward with construction of the proposed arch while legal challenges proceed, highlighting disputes over congressional authority and the project's potential effects on traffic, airport airspace, and nearby historic sites.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

Questions readers ask

Who blocked the construction of Trump's proposed Triumphal Arch?
A second federal judge, U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema, blocked the project, following a temporary block by Judge Tanya Chutkan earlier in the month.
Why did Judge Brinkema rule against the arch construction?
Judge Brinkema stated the plan suffered from multiple legal defects, lacked Congressional approval, and had no evidence that federal officials adequately considered impacts on road traffic and Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport.
What is the current status of the construction timeline?
Judge Chutkan extended her order barring the administration from initiating any construction or demolition until the beginning of December.
Why does the arch construction matter?
The rulings prevent the administration from moving forward with construction while legal challenges proceed, highlighting disputes over congressional authority and the project's potential effects on traffic, airport airspace, and nearby historic sites.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.

Politics

Supreme Court of Canada to rule on Quebec's Bill 21 on Nov. 27

The Supreme Court of Canada will announce its decision on Quebec's secularism law on Nov. 27 at 9:45 a.m., addressing the law's ban on religious symbols for certain public servants and the province's use of the notwithstanding clause.

Checked against 2 sourceswinnipegfreepress.comctvnews.ca