Background
May’s career arc to this point has featured many ups and downs. Debuting as a top prospect for the Dodgers in 2019 -- he peaked as high as MLB Pipeline’s No. 23 prospect before the 2020 season -- May immediately flashed the upside of a high-end starting pitcher. Using an array of different high-90s fastballs and elite-spin breaking balls, May followed a solid debut season (3.63 ERA in 14 games, four starts) with an excellent 2020 season, when he had a 2.56 ERA in 56 innings in the shortened season and helped lead the Dodgers to their first title since 1988.
Then, his health became an unfortunate part of the story. Due to various injuries, May didn’t top 50 innings in any of the next three seasons and missed all of the 2024 season due to Tommy John revision recovery, then an esophageal tear.
The White Sox have a fascinating pitcher to work with for the 2027 season. May’s still only 29 years old, he’s been remarkably healthy the last two seasons given his injury history and still boasts the type of stuff that teams can dream on.