Hermes Vector

Space

ULA Traces Vulcan Failure to Inadequate Fuel Supply to BE-4 Engines

United Launch Alliance says preliminary data indicates the Vulcan rocket's failure was caused by inadequate fuel supply to its first-stage engines, not engine performance, leaving the rocket grounded.

By Hermes Vector

Checked against 4 sourcesspaceflightnow.comnewscord.orgArs Technicaspace.com
Illustration for: ULA Traces Vulcan Failure to Inadequate Fuel Supply to BE-4 Engines

In brief

  • ULA says preliminary data indicates inadequate fuel supply to the BE-4 engines caused the Vulcan failure, not engine performance.
  • The November 15 launch lost 40 Amazon Leo satellites and was ULA’s first outright mission failure since 2006.
  • The FAA is overseeing the ULA-led investigation, which has no return-to-flight date yet.
  • The finding reduces concern about the BE-4 engine for Blue Origin’s New Glenn and for NASA’s Centaur 5 upper-stage plans.

ULA Traces Vulcan Failure to Inadequate Fuel Supply to BE-4 Engines

United Launch Alliance said Wednesday that a preliminary review of flight data points to an inadequate supply of fuel to the Blue Origin-manufactured engines of its Vulcan rocket as the reason Sunday’s launch fell short of orbit with 40 Amazon Leo internet satellites aboard.

The company posted the update at 11 a.m. EST (1600 UTC). ULA uses “booster” to refer to Vulcan’s first stage, which is powered by two methane-fueled BE-4 engines.

“While work remains to determine cause, preliminary indications are that the low booster thrust was the result of inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines, not from the performance of the engines,” the company said.

The finding is not a final cause. ULA did not say which part of the vehicle failed to deliver enough fuel or why. The Federal Aviation Administration will oversee the ULA-led investigation, be involved in every step and approve ULA’s final report, including any corrective actions.

“It is very early in the process, and we want to focus on the data and avoid speculation until the investigation is complete,” the ULA statement reads.

Investigation details

Vulcan lifted off at 12:40 p.m. EST (1740 UTC) Sunday from Space Launch Complex 41 at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station. It was the rocket’s fifth flight and its first since February. The rocket carried 40 Amazon Leo satellites, all of which were lost.

ULA said Tuesday that early indications showed “just after liftoff the launch vehicle experienced low [first stage] performance, resulting in stage separation occurring when the vehicle was low in altitude and below minimal velocity to reach orbit.” The company lost telemetry about 10 minutes into flight.

The Centaur separated and ignited its RL10 engines, ULA President and CEO Mark Peller said Tuesday, but the first stage left it “in such a low-energy state” that it “couldn’t make up for that performance deficit.”

Implications for Blue Origin and NASA

The finding points away from the BE-4 as a culprit for the failure, which carries importance for Blue Origin as the company works to return New Glenn to flight after the rocket exploded on its Cape Canaveral launch pad during a test in May. The two BE-4s powering Vulcan, rated together at more than 1 million pounds of thrust, carried a Blue Origin retrofit designed and tested in the aftermath of the May explosion.

Blue Origin said it worked alongside ULA to review flight data and support the investigation.

“Following the Vulcan anomaly, Blue Origin immediately worked alongside ULA to review flight data and support the investigation,” Blue Origin said in a statement Wednesday. “Together, we identified that the low booster thrust was the result of inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines, not from the performance of the engines. ULA is a valued partner, and we look forward to Vulcan’s return to flight.”

For NASA, ULA’s statements leave intact the record of the Centaur 5, which has flown only on Vulcan. NASA said last month it is pursuing two upper-stage options for the SLS moon rocket on Artemis 4: its current interim cryogenic propulsion stage and a stretched version of the Centaur 5.

Grounding and customer impact

Vulcan is grounded again with no return-to-flight date. The U.S. Space Force, which had sought to use Vulcan to launch national security payloads, and Amazon, which purchased 38 Vulcan launches to boost its Leo satellite internet service to orbit, are waiting.

Amazon lost its largest batch of Leo satellites to date. Had the launch proved a success, it would have brought the number of Leo satellites Amazon has launched to 436. That figure would have pushed the company closer to a first-generation constellation of more than 3,200 satellites.

The loss is ULA’s first outright mission failure since Boeing and Lockheed Martin formed the company in 2006. Three of Vulcan’s five flights have now had problems, though Sunday’s is the only one in which the payload did not reach orbit.

“We truly understand the impact this has on our customers and are committed to returning to flight as safely and quickly as we can,” ULA said Tuesday.

Why it matters

The preliminary findings shift the focus of the investigation from the BE-4 engines themselves to the vehicle’s fuel delivery system. This matters for Blue Origin’s New Glenn program, which uses the same engine family, and for NASA’s consideration of the Centaur 5 upper stage for the Space Launch System moon rocket. With both Vulcan and New Glenn grounded, Amazon’s other booked rides are on Arianespace’s Ariane 6 and SpaceX’s Falcon 9.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.