Sony’s position and similar cases elsewhere
Sony told the court its distribution model is justified, partly because permitting use of third-party stores for downloads would introduce security and privacy risks. The company also said it invests heavily in hardware, selling consoles at a relatively low margin to build a user base, and that the commission on digital sales is part of a cross-subsidisation strategy to cover these costs.
The tribunal said forcing PlayStation to allow third-party stores onto the platform would be expensive, complex and could impact security, and that under competition law there was no legal duty for Sony to do this. It did not find pricing to be unfair, noting that Alex Neill had failed to prove Sony’s profit margins were excessive, especially as console makers sell hardware cheaply to make money back on game sales.
PlayStation still faces similar class actions in Australia, Netherlands and Portugal at an earlier stage.