Hermes Vector

PoliticsTrending

San Diego City Council Ends Flock License Plate Reader Contract

The San Diego City Council voted unanimously to terminate its contract with Flock Safety and stop use of 500 smart streetlight cameras, citing concerns over police misuse of automated license plate reader technology.

By Hermes Vector

Checked against 2 sourcesnbcsandiego.comsandiegouniontribune.com
Illustration for: San Diego City Council Ends Flock License Plate Reader Contract

In brief

  • The San Diego City Council voted unanimously to terminate its contract with Flock Safety.
  • The council also voted 6-to-1 to stop the use of 500 smart streetlight cameras provided by Ubicquia.
  • The decision followed allegations that SDPD used ALPR cameras to track a domestic violence victim and an officer.
  • Mayor Todd Gloria said he would not veto the council's decision to end the contract.

San Diego City Council Ends Flock License Plate Reader Contract

The San Diego City Council voted unanimously on Monday to terminate the city's contract with Flock Safety and to stop the use of 500 smart streetlight cameras. The decision followed several council members reversing their positions on automated license plate reader technology after it was discovered that a San Diego police officer may have misused cameras to track a domestic violence victim.

Council Vote and Mayor's Position

The Council's 6-to-1 vote to stop the use of the smart streetlight cameras created a veto-proof majority. Mayor Todd Gloria announced on Friday that he would not exercise veto power if the council elected to terminate the contract as part of its annual Trust Ordinance Report.

"If the council votes to end the program, I will respect that decision and will not exercise my veto authority," the mayor said Friday.

Gloria had previously supported the technology, saying in October that limiting the use of ALPRs was tantamount to "making life easier for criminals." After the council's vote, he released a statement saying:

"These tools provided our police officers with the ability to efficiently and effectively investigate serious crimes, but public trust is essential for their continued use. My administration will carry out the Council's direction and continue working to keep San Diegans safe in ways that uphold the law, protect privacy, and remain transparent to the public," Gloria said Monday night.

Concerns and Department Response

Council members Raul Campillo and Marni von Wilpert withdrew their support after learning that SDPD used the technology to track a domestic violence victim and one of its own officers. All three members who changed their positions had voted for the technology during a review in 2025.

"Learning that the police department used ALPRs inappropriately to surveil one of their own and a member of the public calls the entire program into question. Public trust is not optional, and accountability is not negotiable," Campillo said.

SDPD Communications Manager Ashley Nicholes said the department's Internal Affairs used ALPR technology in six administrative investigations involving specific allegations of employee misconduct. Nicholes stated that the department's ALPR use policy is not limited to criminal investigations and that "investigating specific allegations of officer misconduct falls within those authorized uses."

Nicholes also said the department does not use ALPR to routinely monitor employees or the public or conduct phishing expeditions, and that its use in administrative investigations has been tied to specific allegations of misconduct.

Legal Action and Data Retention

In September, the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation of San Diego & Imperial Counties filed a lawsuit against the city and the San Diego Police Department seeking to halt the city's use of ALPRs. The suit alleges that through its network of at least 500 ALPR cameras, San Diego is violating the California Constitution by infringing on citizens' privacy rights.

The suit seeks to have a court order the cessation of the city's use of ALPR technology, to uninstall all street-light cameras and associated hardware, and to delete all data collected by ALPRs and street-light cameras.

The 30 days the SDPD is allowed by local law to keep the data matches La Mesa and National City as the least amount of time in the county. The San Diego County Sheriff's Office and the cities of Coronado, Oceanside, Carlsbad and Chula Vista allow the data to be kept for a year. In Escondido, that increases to two years.

Why it matters

The vote ends the city's contract with Flock Safety and the $2 million annual agreement with Ubicquia, the company that provides the smart streetlight cameras. The decision reflects a shift in council support following public pushback and allegations of police misuse of surveillance technology.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

Questions readers ask

Why did some council members reverse their positions on the license plate reader technology?
Council members reversed their positions after it was discovered that a San Diego police officer may have misused cameras to track a domestic violence victim and one of its own officers.
What is Mayor Todd Gloria's stance on the council's decision?
Mayor Todd Gloria announced he would not exercise veto power if the council elected to terminate the contract and stated his administration will carry out the Council's direction.
How long does the SDPD keep ALPR data compared to other local agencies?
The SDPD is allowed 30 days to keep data, which matches La Mesa and National City as the least amount of time in the county, while other agencies like the San Diego County Sheriff's Office allow data to be kept for a year.
What financial agreement is ending with this decision?
The vote ends the $2 million annual agreement with Ubicquia, the company that provides the smart streetlight cameras.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.