Hermes Vector

Politics

Quebec Conservatives Leave Door Open to Religious Symbols Ban for Schoolchildren

Quebec Conservative Leader Eric Duhaime says his party is generally in favor of extending the religious symbols ban to elementary school students but wants implementation details first. The PQ government needs opposition support to advance the proposal.

By Hermes Vector

Also in: Español · Português · Français · Deutsch · हिन्दी · 中文

Checked against 2 sourcesFox Newsglobalnews.ca
Illustration for: Quebec Conservatives Leave Door Open to Religious Symbols Ban for Schoolchildren

In brief

  • Quebec Conservative Leader Eric Duhaime says his party is generally in favor of extending the religious symbols ban to elementary school students.
  • Duhaime said Conservatives want implementation details before taking a clear stand on the proposal.
  • Both the Liberals and Québec solidaire have said they would vote against the proposal.
  • The English Montreal School Board and civil rights groups have criticized the proposed expansion to children.

Quebec Conservatives Leave Door Open to Religious Symbols Ban for Schoolchildren

Quebec Conservative Leader Eric Duhaime is leaving the door open to supporting the Parti Québécois government’s proposal to extend a ban on religious symbols to elementary school students, according to Global News.

Conservative Position

Duhaime said his party is generally in favor of the idea but has not committed to supporting it.

"Generally speaking, we’re in favour, you know, of living in a secular society," Duhaime said.

He also said his party sees a connection between restrictions on religious symbols for public-sector workers and the proposed rules for children in schools.

"The link is that we want to banish religious symbols in the public space, especially within public institutions," he said.

Duhaime pointed specifically to young girls wearing veils at school.

"Like everyone else, we feel uneasy seeing a young girl arrive at school with a veil on her head," he said Monday.

However, Duhaime stopped short of committing his party’s support, saying Conservatives want to know how such a ban would be implemented.

"How are we gonna implement that? Who is going to be responsible? What’s the process?" he said. "We want the details before we have a clear stand."

Opposition and Criticism

Both the Liberals and Québec solidaire (QS) have said they would vote against the proposal.

The possibility of extending the religious symbols ban to children is drawing criticism from the English Montreal School Board and civil rights groups. Joe Ortona, chair of the English Montreal School Board, said legislating what children can wear would cross a line.

"It’s a very slippery slope [to] start legislating what children are allowed or not allowed to wear," Ortona said.

He argued the debate is also distracting from other issues facing the education system. "It’s just inappropriate and I think we’ve completely lost focus on the fact that there are real systemic ongoing problems in education."

Civil rights groups are also calling on the Conservatives to reject the PQ proposal.

"This is really a new low and I think everyone should really be just as outraged as we are that the government would sink this low," said Harini Sivalinga of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association.

Stephen Brown of the National Council of Canadian Muslims questioned what the proposed expansion could mean for children who wear religious symbols.

"Are we really, in Quebec, going to go down the road of watching kids being denied entry to math class because they’re wearing a turban or a kippah?" Brown said.

Context

The proposal would go further than the previous Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) government’s ban on religious symbols for some public-sector workers, which sparked outrage from civil rights groups and a legal challenge that has reached the Supreme Court. The new PQ government has promised to extend the ban to elementary school students.

The minority PQ government will need support from opposition parties to advance its agenda. The debate comes as the Supreme Court’s decision on Bill 21 is expected in the coming weeks.

Why it matters

The Conservative Party’s position could determine whether the PQ government’s proposal to extend the religious symbols ban to elementary school students passes in Quebec’s minority legislature.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

Questions readers ask

Who is the Quebec Conservative Leader mentioned in the article?
Eric Duhaime is the Quebec Conservative Leader.
What proposal is the Parti Québécois government making regarding religious symbols?
The Parti Québécois government has promised to extend the ban on religious symbols to elementary school students.
Which parties have stated they would vote against the proposal?
Both the Liberals and Québec solidaire (QS) have said they would vote against the proposal.
Why is the Conservative Party's position significant?
The Conservative Party’s position could determine whether the proposal passes in Quebec’s minority legislature.
What legal challenge is currently pending regarding religious symbols in Quebec?
A legal challenge regarding the previous Coalition Avenir Québec government’s ban on religious symbols for public-sector workers has reached the Supreme Court, with a decision on Bill 21 expected in the coming weeks.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.