Evidence and Arguments
Prosecutors presented cellphone location data, surveillance footage of his car, and a green Bic barbecue lighter with DNA matching Rinderknecht. They also cited his testimony to investigators, in which he said he "didn’t smell a fire, didn’t see fireworks" on the hill.
Defense attorney Steve Haney argued that prosecutors lacked sufficient physical evidence and suggested fireworks could have sparked the flames. He said the fire scene was publicly accessible for several days before police locked it down, potentially compromising evidence.
A juror identified only as Cameron said the strongest evidence was Rinderknecht’s own testimony and that the panel weighed the evidence carefully.