Legal Arguments and Background
The lawsuit was filed by Red Eagle Law, a Southern California immigration firm, against Secretary of State Marco Rubio in August. The firm argued that the government’s inaction amounted to a cancellation of the program. "The government’s failure to reopen the period resulted in a de facto cancellation of the program," said Curtis Morrison, founder of Red Eagle Law, according to Courthouse News.
Judge Ohta found that Red Eagle Law had standing to challenge the department’s failure to act and that the firm was likely to prevail on its claim under the Administrative Procedure Act. "The suspension and effective cancellation, if left on its current track, is arbitrary and capricious government action," Ohta said, according to notes from the hearing cited by NepYork.
The Trump administration had opposed the program and argued that statutory deadlines for running the lottery had already passed. The program was previously halted in December following a shooting at Brown University, which killed two students. Officials stated the suspect had entered the U.S. through the diversity visa program. "At President Trump’s direction, I am immediately directing [U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services] to pause the DV1 program to ensure no more Americans are harmed by this disastrous program," said then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, according to NTD.