Hermes Vector

World

Italian Defence Minister Criticizes US Restrictions on Ukraine Support

Italy's Defence Minister Guido Crosetto stated that US limits on satellite and intelligence access for Ukraine are a 'major mistake' that risks prolonging the war.

By Hermes-Vector AI Desk

Also in: Español · Português · Français · Deutsch · हिन्दी · 中文

Checked against 2 sourcesBBCyahoo.com

In brief

  • Italian Defence Minister Guido Crosetto called US restrictions on Ukraine support a 'complete mistake, a major mistake.'
  • Crosetto warned that limiting resources risks prolonging the war by signaling weakness to Russia.
  • Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni previously criticized a US deal to buy Russian diesel as a 'very risky choice.'
  • Polls show only 18% of Italians support continuing arms supplies to Ukraine, amid rising energy costs.

Italian Defence Minister Criticizes US Restrictions on Ukraine Support

Italy’s Defence Minister Guido Crosetto has criticized the United States for limiting access to satellite systems and intelligence used by Ukraine to defend against Russian attacks. In an interview with the BBC, Crosetto described the move as a "complete mistake, a major mistake" and warned that it "makes absolutely no sense."

Concerns Over Prolonging the Conflict

Crosetto argued that restricting resources for Ukraine risks prolonging Russia's full-scale invasion rather than facilitating peace. He stated that if Russian President Vladimir Putin perceives weakness on the Ukrainian side, he will believe he can win and continue the war. "Peace will come when Putin is convinced there is a stalemate, that he cannot advance any further," Crosetto said.

The minister emphasized that depriving Ukraine of resources creates weakness. "If [Putin] sees weakness on the Ukrainian side – and if the US deprives Ukraine of resources, that creates weakness – then he will believe he can win. So he will continue the war," he said. "I think that is completely wrong."

Italian Government Stance and Domestic Pressure

This criticism follows recent comments by Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, who called a US deal to buy diesel from Russia a "very risky choice" that would "grant Russia legitimacy." Meloni, who has been a close ally of Ukraine, stated that such moves run counter to efforts to bring Putin to the negotiating table.

Despite government support for Ukraine, domestic opposition is growing. Polls conducted for the Ixè institute in September indicated that only 18% of Italians support continuing to supply arms. Recent protests in Rome saw students chanting, "We want more classroom, not more bombs," while truckers in southern Italy blocked roads over rising fuel prices.

Crosetto acknowledged the difficulty of explaining the need for continued support to citizens facing economic hardship. "It's very hard to explain to a citizen who's having trouble at the petrol pump that we can't give any concessions to Russia right now. But that's the only way to defend the future of that very citizen who's complaining," he said.

Security and Disinformation

The minister also addressed security concerns, noting that cyber-attacks linked to Russia are now routine, with "hundreds every day." He criticized Europe's response as too weak, stating, "You can't win a war... if you don't fight back."

Crosetto dismissed reports of planned drone attacks from container ships in the Mediterranean as unproven and attributed a fire at an arms depot outside Rome in August to "human stupidity" rather than arson. He also blamed an active campaign of disinformation by Moscow for shifting public opinion against Ukraine, targeting "certain political figures... and narratives to weaken the political climate against Russia."

Why it matters

The divergence between Italy's government and public opinion highlights the political challenges facing European leaders as they navigate support for Ukraine amidst economic strain. Crosetto's comments underscore the tension between maintaining military pressure on Russia and addressing domestic concerns about energy costs and resource allocation.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

Questions readers ask

Who criticized the US for restricting Ukraine's access to satellite systems?
Italy’s Defence Minister Guido Crosetto criticized the United States for limiting access to satellite systems and intelligence used by Ukraine. He described the move as a "complete mistake, a major mistake" in an interview with the BBC.
Why does Crosetto believe restricting resources prolongs the conflict?
Crosetto argued that if Russian President Vladimir Putin perceives weakness on the Ukrainian side, he will believe he can win and continue the war. He stated that peace will come only when Putin is convinced there is a stalemate.
What did Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni say about the US deal to buy diesel from Russia?
Giorgia Meloni called the US deal to buy diesel from Russia a "very risky choice" that would "grant Russia legitimacy." She stated that such moves run counter to efforts to bring Putin to the negotiating table.
What do recent polls indicate about Italian public opinion on supplying arms to Ukraine?
Polls conducted for the Ixè institute in September indicated that only 18% of Italians support continuing to supply arms. This reflects growing domestic opposition amidst economic hardship and rising fuel prices.
How did Crosetto respond to reports of planned drone attacks from container ships?
Crosetto dismissed reports of planned drone attacks from container ships in the Mediterranean as unproven. He also attributed a fire at an arms depot outside Rome in August to "human stupidity" rather than arson.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

Advertisement

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.