Hermes Vector

PoliticsTrending

High Court rules Somerset Council tax scheme unlawful in disability case

The High Court has ruled Somerset Council's council tax reduction scheme unlawfully discriminated against disabled resident Andy Mitchell after he moved to Universal Credit.

By Hermes Vector

Also in: Español · Português · Français · Deutsch · हिन्दी

Checked against 3 sourcesburnham-on-sea.comsolicitorsjournal.comBBC
Illustration for: High Court rules Somerset Council tax scheme unlawful in disability case

In brief

  • The High Court ruled Somerset Council's 2025/26 council tax reduction scheme unlawfully discriminated against disabled resident Andy Mitchell.
  • The court found counting two Universal Credit elements as income was irrational and discriminatory with no justification.
  • Andy Mitchell's council tax liability for 2025/26 must be quashed and reassessed.
  • The ruling may affect similar council tax schemes run by other local authorities across England and Wales.

High Court rules Somerset Council tax scheme unlawful in disability case

The High Court has ruled in favour of Somerset resident Andy Mitchell in his judicial review challenge to Somerset Council's council tax reduction scheme.

The ruling

In a judgment handed down on 12 November 2026, the High Court found that the rules in Somerset Council's 2025/26 council tax reduction scheme, by which the limited capacity for work related activity element and the transitional element of Universal Credit are counted towards the calculation of 'income', are unlawful. The judge found the rules are irrational and discriminatory because they treat people who have identical needs differently simply based on the type of benefit they receive, without justification.

The court also concluded that the council failed to comply with its duty under section 149 of the Equality Act to have 'due regard' to the needs of disabled people. The court ruled that the decision regarding Andy's council tax liability must be quashed and his council tax liability for 2025/26 reassessed.

Impact on the claimant

Andy Mitchell said his council tax support was dramatically reduced when he was migrated from legacy benefits onto Universal Credit. Prior to the move, he did not have to pay council tax, but after being reassessed he became liable for more than £1,100 a year despite there being no change in his circumstances, income or needs.

Andy said: "The judgment is a huge relief. When I was moved onto Universal Credit, I was told that my income would be protected and that I would not be worse off financially. Yet I suddenly found myself facing a council tax bill of more than £1,000 a year despite nothing changing about my health, circumstances or needs."

Council response

Cllr Liz Leyshon, Somerset Council's Lead Member for Finance, Procurement & Performance, said: "This case came forward following national changes to benefits which impacted on some local recipients of council tax reduction."

She added: "Supporting residents in need always comes first, but this matter was complex and we believed we responded in the most appropriate way. However, we acknowledge the court's judgement and recognise the impact of the changes on Mr Mitchell."

The council said its immediate priority is to address Mr Mitchell's case, ensure council tax reduction is being assessed lawfully, and establish whether any other residents may be affected. It is considering whether any aspects of the judgement should be asked to be looked at by a higher court, and will review its draft Council Tax Reduction Scheme for 2027/28 in light of the judgment, with proposals to be considered by Executive in early December.

Why it matters

The judgment could have implications for similar council tax schemes operated by local authorities across England and Wales. Andy's lawyers said other local authorities operate schemes that take a similar approach and they expect the judgment to have significant implications beyond Somerset.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.

Questions readers ask

Who won the High Court judicial review challenge against Somerset Council?
Somerset resident Andy Mitchell won the judicial review challenge regarding the council's tax reduction scheme.
What did the High Court rule unlawful about Somerset Council's 2025/26 council tax reduction scheme?
The High Court ruled on 12 November 2026 that counting the limited capacity for work related activity element and the transitional element of Universal Credit towards 'income' calculations was unlawful and discriminatory.
How did the council tax liability change for Andy Mitchell after migrating to Universal Credit?
Andy Mitchell's council tax liability increased to more than £1,100 a year, whereas he previously did not have to pay council tax despite no change in his circumstances or income.
What are Somerset Council's immediate priorities following the judgment?
The council's immediate priority is to address Mr Mitchell's case, ensure council tax reduction is assessed lawfully, and determine if other residents are affected.
Why does this ruling matter beyond Somerset?
The judgment could have implications for similar council tax schemes operated by local authorities across England and Wales, as other authorities use a similar approach.

The day's checked news, by email

One short email a day with the top stories. Free, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

Or follow for the latest news:

How do you feel about this story?

Comments 0

No comments yet. Start the discussion.