Harvard scientist disputes NASA chief over object 1998 KY26
Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb is pushing back on NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman over the classification of near-Earth object 1998 KY26, saying the object is "not an asteroid."
The roughly 36-foot-wide object is believed to be a near-Earth asteroid but is accelerating in a way gravity alone cannot explain. Loeb and his colleagues have examined whether it could instead be Phobos 1, a Soviet spacecraft that stopped communicating while traveling to Mars in 1988.
Isaacman weighed in on the object Thursday during an appearance on "Fox & Friends."
"I've not seen any evidence to suggest this is...anything other than an asteroid," Isaacman said.
Loeb challenged that assessment during an interview with Fox News Digital on Friday.
"Well, first of all, it's not an asteroid because 1998 KY26 appears to have non-gravitational acceleration, meaning it's being pushed by some force other than gravity, and asteroids are just rocks," Loeb said.
Loeb said his team found KY26's trajectory closely resembles that of the failed Soviet mission and calculated that sunlight reflecting off Phobos 1 could produce a push consistent with the nongravitational acceleration observed in KY26. He also pointed to recent observations indicating the object is highly reflective and rotates about once every five minutes.
Loeb rejected the alternative theory that KY26 is a "dark comet," a rocky object behaving like a comet without producing a visible cloud or tail. New research from Georgia Tech has cast doubt on whether KY26 could retain enough ice to produce that effect, while other research has suggested pressure from sunlight and heat radiating from its surface could account for the acceleration.
"We don't see a cometary tail. We don't see any evidence for outgassing around this object. That's the puzzle," he added.
NASA told Fox News Digital that in a paper published in 2025 it completed a comprehensive orbital analysis of near-Earth asteroid 1998 KY26 and concluded its behavior is driven by solar radiation forces. Using recent measurements of the asteroid's shape, size, and rotation, a team led by NASA's Center for Near-Earth Object Studies determined that the asteroid's complex trajectory is due to solar radiation forces, which are the natural push of sunlight and thermal emission on its non-spherical shape.
"This analysis demonstrates the asteroid's path isn't caused by hidden comet-like activity," NASA said.
Loeb acknowledged that his team's theory remains unproven, but said a definitive answer could come in 2031, when the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency's Hayabusa2 spacecraft is expected to rendezvous with KY26.
"We predict that when they land on it, instead of seeing an iceberg, they will find the label ‘Made in the USSR,’" Loeb said.
Asked whether the Phobos 1 theory would be completely over if Hayabusa2 reaches KY26 and finds a rock or piece of ice, Loeb said, "Yes."
Sources
- tech.yahoo.com: Harvard scientist pushes back on NASA chief over mystery space object: 'It's not an asteroid'
- foxnews.com: Avi Loeb says 1998 KY26 is not an asteroid, disputes NASA's Jared Isaacman | Fox News
- journalarta.com: Harvard Scientist Pushes Back on NASA Chief Over Object 1998 KY26 — JournalArta Global
This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.


