Canadian steel industry urges caution on China tariff exemption deal

Canada’s steel industry is urging the government to remain vigilant against illegally dumped imports after Ottawa signed a new deal with China to exempt more Chinese steel products from surtaxes and tariffs.

Prime Minister Mark Carney announced Tuesday that Canada is extending existing tariff exemptions for classes of Chinese steel and aluminum for the next two years, as well as adding another 32 items to that list. He made the announcement after meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen. The government said these items are not manufactured or produced in Canada.

In exchange, China is agreeing to extend a pause on tariffs on Canadian pork and seafood products, as well as canola, peas, crabs and lobster.

Canada currently imposes a 25 per cent surtax on steel derivative products, but uses a remission framework that effectively exempts some products, including those used for key infrastructure projects, auto manufacturing or not produced in Canada. A surtax on Chinese steel has been in place since 2024. Through the remission model, buyers based in Canada can apply to the government for a refund of the duties paid. Canada first opened the remission framework to some Chinese steel products earlier this year.

A senior source with the steel sector told iPolitics that it appears the government is mostly permitting steel products from China that aren’t manufactured in Canada and were flagged as part of industry consultations. However, the final list of products covered by the revised remissions framework has yet to be released.

The source, who asked not to be identified to speak freely, said the fear is that China will use this expanded access to dump other classes of steel to get around the existing restrictions regime. After the surtax was imposed in 2024, Chinese steel imports dropped by nearly 50 per cent last year.

"Our greatest fear is to see these remissions being used as some sort of a loophole or a way to reverse the significant progress we’ve made in blocking Chinese steel from, you know, flooding our market," the source said, noting that imports are continuing to drop even after Canada opened the remission regime to some Chinese products.

"We had those remission in place and we were still able to curb our imports from Chinese steel, which is a good sign. But we need to be careful that we’re not going to reverse those gains."

The source warned that Chinese producers have been known to deliberately misclassify shipments and if Canada isn’t careful, these imports can flood the market and undercut domestic manufacturers.

"They are the the worst trade offender in the marketplace. If you look at our trade remedy system, over 35 per cent of all the trade measures we have in place are for China," the source noted.

Liberal MP John-Paul Danko defended the deal during a brief interview with iPolitics on Tuesday, saying that Canada is only permitting "specialty items" from China that "can’t be produced here or aren’t available." Danko, a vice-chair on the all-party steel caucus, said the government is working on building domestic capacity to manufacture more steel products, but would need to permit some imports in the meantime to keep costs down.

"We don’t want to disadvantage Canadian industrial suppliers or manufacturers… that need access to the global market for the products at a price point that Canadians can afford."

Danko said Canada is protecting against dumped steel by tracking melting and pour standards, and illegal imports are "not currently an issue." He said it’s the Americans that are actually the biggest rival to Canadian steel producers, making up nearly half of all imports.

"When you look at it the other way from the Canadian perspective, it’s by far American exports into Canada that’s the problem. When it’s over half of the market, it’s significant."

Canada’s rapprochement with China has drawn concern from the Trump administration, which has warned Canada against becoming a backdoor for Chinese goods destined for the U.S. After news of the deal broke, Peter Navarro, a trade adviser to Trump, accused Canada in a social media post of trying to play "China off the U.S.," and warned that China is "going to eat Canada alive."

The U.S. parent company of Stelco recently announced that it was halting production at facilities in Ontario because of the impact of U.S. tariffs and blamed Canada for not doing enough to stop the flow of Chinese steel into the marketplace.


Sources

This article was drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. Company claims are reported as claims. Cover image is AI-generated.